Skip to content

For a Memorable Celebration!

Sculpted & Fondant Cakes

Use our Cake Order Form to get a no-obligation quote or visit our online store and order a classic buttercream cake and make every birthday special with a custom birthday cake from Eat My Sweets Bakery!

Order a Classic Buttercream Cake Online and Pick-Up in Store!

Why do bakery cakes cost more than grocery and big-box store cakes?

That's a good question. Let's compare bakery-made cakes like those from Eat My Sweets Bakery to those cakes from grocery and big-box stores like Costco:

Is the cake... Bakery Cake Grocery & Big-Box Store Cake
Baked especially for your order? Yes. We bake our cakes especially for each order. No. Cakes are baked in big batches in-store or offsite at a factory on a cake-line
Frosted with buttercream made ONLY with fresh, unsalted butter, 35% whipping cream and flavoured with natural extracts and/or real chocolate? Yes. Whipped light and creamy for each cake. Our buttercream is also less sweet than what you'll get from a grocery or big box store because we don't have to mask the oily texture and chemical extract flavour with extra sugar. No. Frosting at grocery and big-box store bakeries are made from edible oil products and use articifial flavouring and chocolate compounds.
Is the cake decorated by hand? Yes. Whether it's a simple birthday cake with buttercream flowers and swirls or a fondant-covered theme cake, we carefully hand-decorate every cake with creativeity and pride. No. Grocery and big box cakes are produced on a cake line. The machines are fun to watch on Youtube, but the cakes all look the same, lacking the personality and flair of a hand-decorated cake.

Puzzled about what cake to order? 

Not sure what kind of cake you want or how big it should be?  Check out our page on cake shapes, sizes and servings to learn about what's possible and then give us a call or send a note and we'll help you further with any questions you have.

Scroll To Top