We want everyone who visits Eat My Sweets Bakery to feel welcome and - most importantly - safe.

That's why all our products are made with factory packaged ingredients bearing labels that include allergy warning statements.

We have also contacted manufacturers of base ingredients, including flour, to verify their peanut and tree nut safety.

While we don't have 100% control over the manufacture of our ingredients, we've done our darnedest to ensure we're a 100% peanut and tree nut free bakery.

Of course, those with very severe allergic sensitivity should exercise their usual personal discretion.


What Our Customers Say...

Melissa Barnhartg,tf
Melissa Barnhartg,tf
I got exactly what I ordered. The buttercream is real buttercream which is hard to find these days I find. It never has that richness.
Gurpreet Kaur
Gurpreet Kaur
Ordered Christmas and regular squares. They were all very tasty, I personally loved the Apple crumble and Ginger Blondies
Absolutely delighted to have discovered this elegant and welcoming bakery. I visited today and was assisted by Michelle, an incredibly helpful, courteous, and professional individual. She answered all of my questions with a smile and helped alleviate any concerns I had regarding possible tree nut/peanut ingredients. She took my cake order and asked exactly how I wanted my custom order to be made. I tasted the chocolate and vanilla cupcakes and they were absolutely delicious. I am picking up my cake this Saturday and will update my review with pictures! Can't wait!
Syed Hussain
Syed Hussain
Today I bought different short breads and strawberry vanilla jam from sweet & eats first time. All items were amazingly tasty and of no 1 quality. I noticed that the top quality is because of pure butter used in baking products, otherwise the bakers mostly use oil which affects the quality badly. Again soon I will go to Eat My Sweets and try other items too. I recommend if someone like quality baking products he must visit E M S.
Eat My Sweets made all my vintage style wedding cake dreams come true! The cake looked so stunning. It's like they took the image from my imagination and made it real. Nailed the style, the heart was so cute, and the piping was perfect. They even added shimmer to make it shine. It also tasted amazing. All our guests commented on how delicious it was. Perfect amount of icing and so moist. The lemon flavour is simply to die for. My husband is already talking about ordering another cake to enjoy at home!
Nadia Soranno
Nadia Soranno
This is my go to place for tasty nut free dessert options. The cakes/pies are beautifully made and delicious!! Our family’s favourite is the tiramisu and the apple pie. I also love that you can order online! It’s very easy/user friendly, and they have lovely pictures of all the desserts. Customer service is wonderful as well. They always call to ensure that my order is correct. This is another reason why we keep ordering from this company-super organized and always friendly.
A Farooq
A Farooq
Stopped by around 3:30pm to try their selection. They were actually sold out of many selections. Picked the double chocolate, lemon pie, and 3 various cheese cake offers. Wow!!! Really good stuff. The staff member was friendly and cordial.

PLEASE note that we are NOT a gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan, or keto bakery.

We are a dedicated peanut and tree nut free bakery. Many of the substitutions for such baking are nut-based and we will not compromise the safety of our nut/peanut allergic customers by bringing nuts or peanuts into our bakery.


We're 100% peanut and tree nut free logo

When we decided the bakery would be a peanut and tree nut free zone, Lucky was thrilled to hear he would have all the peanuts and tree nuts for himself! In fact, he was so ecstatic, he agreed to be our mascot...making us all very happy.


Because we want everyone to have their share of treats, we do not use any alcoholic ingredients in baking (with the exception of all-natural extracts) or in finishing our products unless expressly requested when placing a custom order.

Everything we make is mixed as an individual batch and there is no cross-mixing.  Any flavours - such as our Guinness Specialty Cupcakes or Irish Cream Nanaimo Bars - will always declare alcoholic content in their name.

We have cake...plus a whole lot more!
And EVERYTHING is peanut & tree nut free...

Choosing is always a "Homer" moment....

Not only do we love baking but we love experimenting!

Click on "Products" in the menu and check out our galleries of goodies.  No only can you order our classic Chocolate, Lemon, or Vanilla buttercream cakes in whatever size or shape you need, but you'll also find find an imaginative variety of Brownies, Blondies & Squares, Cupcakes, Cookies, and Individual and Family Sized Treats...every one of which is guaranteed to make your mouth water.

We've also got  our Specialty Cakes & Cake LoavesCheesecakes, Pies, Tarts & Quiches, and Home-Style Bread and  Scones. Which taste great topped with our exclusive line of full fruit, home-made jams.

Remember, no matter what you choose to satisfy your sweet tooth, everything is made with fresh butter, real cream, and all-natural extracts and flavourings....and everything is safely peanut and tree nut free!


Check out some gorgeous cakes in the carousel below. To get ideas for your own custom cake, click the button to go to our filterable cake gallery page and see our cakes by category.

Since completing George Brown College's highly regarded Baking and Pastry Arts program, Michelle, the owner and baker behind Eat My Sweets Bakery, has not only been applying her talents to creating everyday treats but has also been creating sculpted cakes for her clients' special celebrations.

Whether you want to celebrate a notable birthday, need a baby shower surprise gender-reveal cake or a spectacular wedding or silver anniversary cake with intricately hand-sculpted flowers, Michelle will bring her creativity and skill to interpret your vision.

The possibilities in both form and flavour are endless. But, please keep in mind that every celebration cake order begins with a one-on-one consultation and requires at least one week's notice, so be sure to contact Michelle in advance of your event to avoid disappointment!

Not sure what kind of cake you want or how big it should be?  Check out our page on cake shapes, sizes and servings to learn about what's possible and then give us a call or send a note and we'll help you further with any questions you have.

Satisfy your cookie cravings are our NEW Cookie Bar!
Cookie Monster promised not to eat ALL the cookies if we let him keep watch over the cookie jars.


Order Online and Pick-Up in Store!

While the entire family loves to bake, Zia Sia (Michelle and her sister, Grace's childhood name for their Aunt Silvia) has a special talent for making incredible jams. Not only are they delicious but she makes up incredible flavours you can't get anywhere else.

After years of urging her to market the jams, we're thrilled we can finally share the goodness with everyone and offer "Zia Sia's Jams" exclusively here at Eat My Sweets Bakery!

Every variety is made with simple, all-natural ingredients and in small batches to ensure optimal flavour. Each 500 ml jar is finished with its own whimsical tag and bow and make fantastic gifts.

Scroll and click through imaginative flavour combinations above or, better yet, come in and try them for yourself.  You'll be addicted from your first spoonful!