Individual Sized Treats
-
Individual Sweet Treats
Price range: $2.50 through $8.00 Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
-
- Christmas & Hanukkah Treats
- Shop All Categories
- Get a Custom Cake Quote!
- Classic Buttercream Cakes
- Specialty Cakes & Cake Loaves
- Blondies, Brownies, Nanaimo Bars & Squares
- Cupcakes
- Holiday Menus
- Cookies
- Hand-Decorated Sugar Cookies
- Cheesecakes
- Pies, Tarts & Quiches
- Family Size Treats
- Individual Sized Treats
- Bread & Scones
- Zia Sia’s Yummy Jams
- Testimonials
×
-
- Christmas & Hanukkah Treats
- Shop All Categories
- Get a Custom Cake Quote!
- Classic Buttercream Cakes
- Specialty Cakes & Cake Loaves
- Blondies, Brownies, Nanaimo Bars & Squares
- Cupcakes
- Holiday Menus
- Cookies
- Hand-Decorated Sugar Cookies
- Cheesecakes
- Pies, Tarts & Quiches
- Family Size Treats
- Individual Sized Treats
- Bread & Scones
- Zia Sia’s Yummy Jams
- Testimonials
Please note we are closed January 1st to January 5th, 2026.
We'll be open again January 6th to welcome you with sweetness for 2026!
What Our Customers Say...
EXCELLENTTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I have been ordering my daughter’s birthday cakes from this bakery for many years, and they never disappoint. The cakes are always absolutely delicious and beautifully designed. You can truly see the care and attention that goes into every detail. The owner is incredibly kind and genuinely caring, which makes the whole experience even more special. I can’t recommend them enough for both quality and service!!Posted onTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. HEAVEN ON EARTH.......Posted onTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I got cupcakes from Eat My Sweets for a gender reveal, and they were the tastiest cupcakes I think I’ve ever had. They provided excellent service and I’m glad I chose them for this special moment.Posted onTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. We ordered a bunch of sweets for our wedding and they were FLAWLESS. They were delivered to the restaurant and looked amazing but tasted even better it was mindblowing how good they were. It was such a relief to have something guaranteed nut free and nothing went to waste. The service when we were ordering things was professional and exceptionally helpful - everything was seamless and hassle-free. We will definitely be popping in on Main St for snacks in the future. Thank you all for helping to make our wedding day even more perfect 🤗💕Posted onTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Family-owned, and you really get the care and love they put into everything they do. Thank you for choosing Milton as your home; we really needed a nut-free bakery here—ingredients like Nona used to bake with! Everything is delicious! Looking forward to your expanding menu 😋Posted onTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Super cute cafe inside , quiet nice staff and yummy treats - will returnPosted onTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. The Lime Zinger blondie had that smooth dense cake consistency topped with lime-flavoured frosting. SO GOOD! The mini caramel cheesecake was a decadent perfectly-sized bite of dulche de Leche heaven. I also got their frozen drink which was similar in flavour to a Brazilian lemonade - perfect for a July afternoon. I'd definitely return to try other treats!