During the lockdown, walk-ins are limited to one customer at a time. So, to serve you faster, SAME DAY order pick-up is available for our best-sellers.

For same-day pick-up, call us at 905-858-3490 between 10:00 am and noon to place your order and schedule your pick-up time.

For large quantities or to ensure getting your personal favourites, we ask that you call at least 24 hours in advance of your desired pick-up date/time or that you place your order through our online shop. As usual, please use our cake quote request form for your custom cakes and our school/corporate/event quote form for large quantity orders.


Blondies, Brownies, Bars & Squares

Bars, Blondies, Brownies, and Squares. Oh my!

If you've been to Eat My Sweets you know these are our specialty!  When you're sweet tooth demands to satisfaction, why settle for the same old cupcake or a treat you can find anywhere? Come check out our selection of delectable square-shaped temptations for something as special as you are. 

Unique flavours like Birthday Cake Blondie, Elvis Presley Blondie, Rolo Brownie, Extreme Chocolate Brownie, Apple Caramel Square, and our famous Brookie (half brownie/ half chocolate chip cookie for when you need to have both). Ever eaten Millionaire's Shortbread Bar or an Irish Cream, Mint, Orange, or Raspberry Nanaimo Bar?  You can now!

Plus, we're always testing out new and wonderful flavour combinations to keep things interesting so you never know what you'll find when you pop by the bakery. 

Bringing dessert somewhere? Our squares are a crowd favourite. Ask us to half or quarter your squares and we'll package them for serving. You'll be the favourite guest (and do it economcially too!)

PRO-TIP: Ready-to-go, in-store flavours are rotated so order online to be sure you get all your favourites!