Custom Thanksgiving Orders Through the Online Store are Now Closed

Please visit us in-store on Saturday to purchase from our ready-made selection!

We're open and we're ready to serve you!

With recent changes to physical distancing legislation, we're thrilled to welcome you back inside the bakery.  But walk-in selection IS limited to ensure freshness so to ensure you get exactly what you need (and crave), we strongly recommend calling ahead (905-858-3490) or placing an order through our online shop. As usual, please use our cake quote request form for your custom cakes.

Curbside pick-up is still available to ensure your comfort and safety!

Place Your Order
Get a Cake Quote

OUR CLIENTS ARE FAMILY

TESTIMONIALS

Nothing makes us happier than knowing we made our clients happy.

We know that every event you bring our baking to is important. Whether it's a summertime sunny afternoon's BBQ or a 50th wedding anniversary, your aim is to make your family and friends feel special and taken care of.

That's why we take a lot of care in fulfilling every order to make sure we deliver beyond your expectations.

Our perspective is that when you order from Eat My Sweets Bakery, you become a friend and part of our family.  And making you feel special and taken care of is our aim. 

Euchre Themed Custom Birthday Cake. Eat My Sweets Bakery.

Joanne

Euchre Themed Custom Birthday Cake

I just wanted to say thank you again to you and your family – once again you have outdone yourselves.

The Birthday Cake was delicious and the decorations were amazing (so life like) and your attention to detail is outstanding. My family thought the cake was delicious and were going back for seconds.

I can’t think of another bakery I’d even think of going to – right from the very beginning you have made me feel like I’m part of the family. I wish you nothing but the best!

Silver Anniversary 2-tier cake by Eat My Sweets Bakery

Jenny V.B.

40th Anniversary - Ruby and Silver Celebration Cake

It was such a pleasure working with Eat My Sweets Bakery. I ordered a 40th wedding anniversary cake for my parents and Michelle worked with me on the concept and design of the cake. It turned out beautifully. It not only was beautiful to look at, it was delicious too! The customer service far exceeded my expectations. I will definitely be ordering from Eat My Sweets Bakery again. Thank you 🙂

Testimonials from Eat My Sweets Bakery

Julia L.

Custom Thomas the Tank Cake & Cookies

Eat My Sweets exceeded my expectations, aside from the amazing quality and taste of my cake and cookies the creativity and perfection of delivery was second to none. The ordering process was easy, quick & accurate, delivery was on time - can't wait to order for my next corporate or personal event!

 
Testimonials from Eat My Sweets Bakery

Donna S.

1st Communion with 3-D Bible & Chalice Celebration Cake

I just wanted to send a big thank you, and to let you know that the cake was wonderful. Everybody loved it! They raved about how great it tasted, it really made a Neo's day. It was just one less thing to worry about, and it made the sweet table look just gorgeous. Thank you for all your work, and I hope that the business is extremely successful.

Testimonials from Eat My Sweets Bakery

Lorraine B.

Lemon Birthday Cake with Glazed Fresh Berries

My stepdaughter and her family couldn't say enough about your fabulous cake. They went on & on, including my husband, saying it was the best cake they had ever tasted. A real hit! THANK YOU!

Testimonials from Eat My Sweets Bakery

Julia L.

Custom Thomas the Tank Cake & Cookies

Eat My Sweets exceeded my expectations, aside from the amazing quality and taste of my cake and cookies the creativity and perfection of delivery was second to none. The ordering process was easy, quick & accurate, delivery was on time - can't wait to order for my next corporate or personal event!

 
Lucky the Squirrel Logo. Eat My Sweets Bakery

Deanna H.

Lego Themed Celebration Birthday Cake

Thank you so much for the WONDERFUL LEGO cake for my girl’s birthday. It was gorgeous & tasty! She absolutely loved it & everyone was impressed. We will be ordering more from you in the near future!

Testimonials from Eat My Sweets Bakery

Mona K.

Wedding Celebration Cake & Cupcakes

The cake and cupcakes were delicious as I knew they would be!!!! Thank you for setting up with such ease, we really appreciate it! Thanks!

Life Sized Scultped Guitar Cake

Cathy C.

Life Size Guitar Celebration Cake

"I wanted you to know that your cake was a huge success. The candles looked great on it, almost like broken guitar strings! It was really really moist and the icing was nice and sugary just the way I like it!"

Ice Age Birthday Cake

Anna P.

Ice Age Themed Specialty Cake

The cake was a big hit with my dad and the rest of my family enjoyed it as well. My dad took the longest time to blow out his candles because he was laughing so hard. Thank you!

 
Baptism Cupcake Cake. Eat My Sweets Bakery

Anissa K.

Custom Baptism Tear-away Cupcake Cake

Michelle did an amazing job on our baptism tear away cupcake cake and cross cookies. It was a hit at our party! I loved that the cupcake cake matched the picture I had sent her and the price was very reasonable. Both her and her mom are so friendly and take so much pride in their work they both do. Thank you for a wonderful experience. It was our first time ordering from them and it will not be our last. We have many more parties coming up!

Testimonials from Eat My Sweets Bakery

Rachel R.

Chocolate, Vanilla & Red Velvet Birthday Cupcakes

Thee most decadent and delicious cupcakes I've ever had. The flavour and texture are out of this world, along with the right amount of delicious frosting that knocked me off my feet. They are beautifully priced for the quality of cupcakes. My rating for these little treats are 10/10. Thank you for making my event that much more special.

Testimonials from Eat My Sweets Bakery

Maria D.

Brownie with Cream Cheese Frosting

I just tried Michelle’s Cream Cheese Brownie, it was absolutely amazing! I couldn’t believe how fresh and delicious all of the ingredients tasted, just the perfect amount of tasty rolled into a neat little square! Thank you Michelle for giving me a wonderful treat to make my day even sweeter!

Testimonials from Eat My Sweets Bakery

Joanne & Bill

Silver Anniversary Celebration Cake

WOW you really outdid yourself. There wasn’t a thing that you didn’t do that we asked for. Everything about our 25th Anniversary Cake was magnificent. Your gum paste flowers looked real – outstanding. The flavour of the cake was fabulous – so moist and flavourful. Our guests were so impressed with your baking abilities. Thanks again for making our day so special. I would happily refer you to our friends and family to get all of their baking needs from Eat My Sweets.

Testimonials from Eat My Sweets Bakery

Maria J.

Doctor's Coat Celebration Cake

"The cake was a great hit. Very fresh and not too sweet. Plenty of photos taken with it. Dr. Hill really appreciated it."